This hymn is a prayer, in which we ask for God’s wisdom and courage to face the problems of our day. We beg for God’s power, confess our fear and pride, and affirm a desire to seek social justice.
Harry E. Fosdick was a well-known and controversial preacher in the early twentieth century. After Fosdick left his positon at one church, John D. Rockefeller asked him to become pastor of Park Avenue Baptist Church in New York City, but Fosdick thought the church was too wealthy, and agreed only on condition that a new church would be built in a less fashionable place. The site selected for Riverside Church was on the banks of the Hudson, not far from Harlem. Fosdick wrote this hymn at his summer home in Maine in 1930 for the opening service of Riverside Church that fall. It was sung as the processional hymn for that service on October 5 and again at the dedication service on February 8, 1931. The first publication was in Praise and Service by H. Augustine Smith in 1932.
This hymn is a prayer for God’s help for the church to live in God’s power and love with generosity and progress toward social justice. Each stanza concludes with a two-line petition for wisdom and courage that was originally meant to be sung to one musical phrase. However, when it is sung to CWM RHONDDA, the final line of each stanza must be repeated to extend the text to fit the tune. This results in a needless repetition of the second part of the petition.
CWM RHONDDA is a well-known Welsh tune. It was written in 1907 by John Hughes, a Welshman who spent most of his life as a railway worker. The tune name literally means “Rhondda valley,” after the Rhondda River that flows through a coal-mining district of Wales. This tune has great vigor, and was at first circulated only in leaflet form because hymnal editors considered it too vigorous to be a proper hymn
Fosdick did not like the use of this tune for his text, having written it specifically to fit the three phrases of the tune REGENT SQUARE. When asked about the tune change, he wrote, “My secretary has already written you the answer to your question about my hymn’s divorce from ‘Regent Suqare’ and remarriage to ‘Cwm Rhondda.’ The Methodists did it! And both here and abroad they are being followed” (quoted in Hymnal Companion to Evangelical Lutheran Worship, Paul Westermeyer, p. 562).
This hymn was written as an opening hymn, and is suitable for a service with a theme of the Church’s role in the world. With the large number of arrangements of this tune, one can easily see why hymnal editors had to yield to popular pressure to include this tune in their hymnals. The frequent use of brass instruments shows off the vigor of the tune.
“God of Grace and God of Glory” is a majestic arrangement for handbells, calling for a variety of techniques and an optional trumpet. The middle section goes to a minor key and is more subdued. A brass solo based on CWM RHONDDA, titled “Guide Me, O Thou Great Jehovah” after the text for which the tune is famous, is available for trumpet, trombone, and tuba. In his setting of “God of Grace and God of Glory,” Joel Raney sets the text to his own original music as well as CWM RHONDDA, employing at a minimum a SATB choir and piano, but with additional optional reinforcement from organ, handbells, trumpets, and percussion. A majestic choral arrangement of “God of Grace and God of Glory” calls for organ, brass quintet, and optional percussion to accompany the congregation and adult and children’s choirs. Changing meters in some phrases add vitality and interest.